For everyday businesses and organizations, choosing an access control system is pivotal, as an effective solution is the key to security and efficiency. ProdataKey (PDK) and DMP X1 are two important contenders in cloud-based access, each bringing a unique set of features and functionalities to the table. This article will explore their differences, delivering insight to guide businesses in selecting their ideal solution.
Who is PDK?
Founded in 2011 and headquartered in Draper, UT, ProdataKey pioneered mobile-first access control. The ProdataKey mobile app is the centerpiece of every PDK system, offering end-users touch-free access, convenient on-the-go management, and robust features. At the same time, PDK’s Open API supports various 3rd-party integrations critical to modern organizations. With diverse hardware options and advanced cloud infrastructure, PDK systems are equipped for systems big and small operating in markets ranging from residential, commercial, and government.
Who is DMP?
The DMP X1 access control system represents a sophisticated security and facility management solution. X1 is engineered by DMP, a family-owned independent manufacturer of intrusion, fire, access control, and cellular alarm solutions located in Springfield, MO. Like PDK, DMP X1 has OSDP and Wiegand support, PoE power options, varying credentials, and mobile access capabilities. A standout feature of DMP X1 is its integrated cellular service; systems can be hardwired with ethernet, WiFi, or optional AT&T/Verizon cellular. Most aspects of the system are managed through the Virtual Keypad (VK) app or browser.
VMS Integration
Access control integration with video management systems is integral to any comprehensive security solution. By combining the two platforms, organizations gain a seamless, efficient approach to security management. Significant steps may be required to integrate specific VMS systems with DMP X1, and some interoperability may be limited. Bookmarking access control events like soft triggers or forced alarms may be unavailable for some integrated XP1 and VMS systems.
With upcoming integration enhancements, a new marketplace for VMS integrations with Hanwha and Digital Watchdog will be available within PDK.io, ProdataKey’s software platform. The new marketplace will deliver ready-to-use VMS integrations, making systems more straightforward to set up than ever before. Access and video technologies are fully interoperable, offering centralized monitoring and control over both systems under one unified platform. Users can investigate, create bookmarks, and trigger access events directly from the integrated VMS.
Hardware Options
Flexible hardware options are essential for optimal system design and overall cost reduction. DMP X1 has limited hardware choices: a single and an eight-door controller and an elevator controller, along with PoE power add-on options. As mentioned above, X1 controllers support Ethernet or Wi-Fi communication with optional cellular as a primary or backup. WiFi-only controllers may present functionality risks, as they depend entirely on the customer network.
ProdataKey offers an extensive range of door controller and peripheral hardware options, catering to a broader spectrum of project sizes. PDK’s controller lineup includes controllers ranging from a single door all the way up to the PDK Red Max, a customizable controller with the power to scale up to 24 doors, along with the A8 auxiliary controller, which supports all other devices, such as DPS and elevator controls.
PDK controllers come standard with Ethernet communication; however, wireless module add-on kits are available to bring controllers online with PDK’s proprietary WiMac network. The WiMac option provides higher network security than standard WiFi and more flexibility to scale systems. WiMac add-ons are a helpful tool to extend access to remote sites, or outdoor applications where running cable isn’t possible.
Reporting Capabilities
In access control, effective reporting capabilities are the key to boosting security, monitoring activities, and ensuring compliance. Robust reporting features provide administrators valuable insight into access activities and potential security threats. They must also be easy to access and navigate; the quicker the admin can view reports, the faster they can take action. X1 offers five basic report types; administrators must download the reports manually to access them.
ProdataKey excels at providing comprehensive and user-friendly reporting tools. The platform offers customizable reports, enabling users to tailor their audits based on People, Credentials, and Events to identify key information quickly. Reporting is readily available for easy use on both the PDK.io web browser and the ProdataKey mobile app.
So when it comes to ProdataKey vs DMP X1, which is the best option for you? ProdataKey and DMP X1 each have valuable features and capabilities, but ultimately, the choice between the two depends on the specific needs of the business or organization. Integrators have long seen PDK and DMP X1 as comparable solutions; however, they significantly differ in VMS integrations, hardware options, and reporting capabilities. The access control game is crowded, but PDK is already a stand-out choice, and it is committed to staying at the forefront.
